New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing criticism over his dramatically different appearance and the tone of a new video announcing changes to the city’s police department.
Political commentator Steve Krakauer, executive producer of The Megyn Kelly Show, took aim at Mamdani, 35, in an X post on Monday, November 16, questioning the mayor’s presentation after he traded his neatly trimmed beard for a thick mustache.
In the video, Mamdani sat in front of a fireplace, flanked by American and New York City flags, sporting a thick, dark mustache in place of his usual closely trimmed beard. He wore a dark suit, white shirt and patterned red-and-gold tie as he addressed the camera about restructuring the New York Police Department.
“This video is alarming because Mamdani seemingly doesn’t care about aesthetics anymore. It comes across as dark and brusque. It’s poorly edited,” Krakauer wrote.
“He doesn’t have to try to seem safe and friendly, he’s in DGAF mode,” he added.
X/NYCMayor
The post sparked a debate in the comments section, with some criticizing Mamdani’s presentation and others suggesting his appearance and delivery were deliberate.
“Didn’t take long for the fake smile to come off did it,” one commenter wrote.
Another disagreed with Krakauer’s assessment, writing, “Not true – the aesthetics of the video are very carefully calculated.”
A third insisted, “Don’t be silly. It’s intentional. He has the best media skills in America and most talented team.”
Mamdani debuted his mustache earlier this month.
“Thousands of people, including Mayor Mamdani, are sporting mustaches this ‘Movember’ to raise awareness about men’s health issues, including mental health disorders, testicular cancer and prostate cancer,” his press secretary Joe Calvello told JNS. “This month, we encourage all New Yorkers to learn their family medical history and talk to their doctor about regular screenings.”
X/NYCMayor
The video addressed Mamdani’s decision to disband the NYPD‘s Strategic Response Group, which handled counterterrorism operations and crowd management.
As Globe previously reported, per the mayor’s official statement, the overhaul will establish a civilian-led division to help manage demonstrations, while counterterrorism duties will shift to the department’s existing Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau.
The changes also restrict certain police crowd-control tactics, including the use of tear gas and kettling, which involves surrounding protesters to restrict their movement.