Lindsay Clancy Trial Juror Says Patrick Clancy’s Testimony Helped Sway Her Vote in Defendant’s Favor

One moment from Lindsay Clancy‘s murder trial stuck with one juror more than any other — watching Patrick Clancy, the grieving father at the center of the case — show compassion for his former wife throughout the proceedings.

Kellie Farina, one of three jurors who spoke out following Friday’s mistrial, told NBC10 Boston on Tuesday, September 8, that Patrick’s compassion for Lindsay left a lasting impression as the panel weighed whether she was not guilty by reason of insanity.

Lindsay, 36, has admitted to killing her three children with former husband Patrick, 38 — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months — at the family’s Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington “brought all these people in, people that loved her, her family, her in-laws. Even Patrick was very compassionate,” Farina said of the witnesses, noting that through their testimony, jurors were able to get a clear picture “of who Lindsay is and what her life was like.”

Patrick’s role in the case has faced intense online scrutiny, with baseless conspiracy theories accusing him of involvement in the deaths, despite no evidence and no charges against him.

Farina recalled how Patrick’s 911 call, played for jurors during the trial, left a deep impact.

“It’s something I’ll never not hear if I think about it. It was the most horrific thing,” she said. “It’s something that will stick with me. And I felt that it was genuine, it was absolutely genuine.”

Foreperson Roni Carlson said the panel’s focus centered on Lindsay’s mental state rather than whether she committed the killings.

“We weren’t trying to figure out if she murdered the children. She did and she’s admitting that. We’re trying to figure out did she know right from wrong at that time?” she said.

Juror Paula Devlin echoed the sentiment toward defense attorney Reddington, calling his approach effective despite his intensity. “His compassion towards Lindsay was amazing,” she said.

Since the mistrial, Patrick’s attorneys have issued two statements reflecting the toll the case has taken on him.

One came hours after the judge declared a mistrial. The statement Fox News obtained addressed the “extraordinarily painful” prospect of another trial.

In another statement released on Tuesday, September 8, Patrick’s attorney Howard Cooper later condemned what he called “vile” and “outright false” online conspiracy theories attempting to link Patrick to his children’s deaths, warning that the attacks had led to real-life threats.

The criminal case against Lindsay remains unresolved.

Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz has not announced whether prosecutors will seek a second trial, and the case is due back in court on Tuesday, September 29.

Reddington said on Wednesday that he plans to ask the judge to dismiss the charges at that hearing on double jeopardy grounds.

Reddington also came to Patrick’s defense during Wednesday’s appearance on CBS Mornings, calling what Patrick has endured “horrific” and saying he is “entitled to move on with his life.”

He also pointed to the anguish heard in Patrick’s 911 call as a reason he rejects the conspiracy theories surrounding him.

If you or someone you know is contemplating suicide or struggling with suicidal thoughts, help is available 24 hours a day through the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. Text 988 or chat at 988lifeline.org.