Ingram Publishing/Newscom/The Mega Agency; Broward County Jail
A Florida man was arrested after allegedly sending his ex-wife’s best friend a letter smeared with peanut butter, despite knowing she had a life-threatening allergy.
According to an arrest affidavit viewed by Globe, police arrested Joseph Gerard Cancellare on November 13 and charged him with one count of aggravated battery and two counts of culpable negligence over the incident that allegedly took place in August 2025.
The woman, who knew Cancellare, checked her mail and observed an envelope that appeared greasy. When she opened it, she noticed a brown substance smeared all over the letter inside that she quickly identified as peanut butter. The woman later told police that she had a life-threatening allergy to peanut butter and quickly dropped the letter and ran inside to wash her hands.
She said she experienced hives and a tingling sensation on both arms for six hours after the very brief contact with the peanut butter. Not only is she allergic to the substance if she touches or ingests it, but even breathing in particles in the air can cause her a severe allergic reaction.
iStock
Police began an investigation and determined that the Forever stamps used on the envelope were purchased through the United States Postal Service. With the help of the Postal Service, they were able to track the specific sale to a kiosk that takes pictures of every customer. That’s how they were eventually able to identify Cancellare as the person who purchased the stamps and, as police allege, sent the letter.
The affidavit further states that Cancellare had expressed a desire to harm the alleged victim to others in their friend group, believing she was responsible for his contentious divorce from her best friend.
The alleged victim stated that, because she and her partner had dinner multiple times with Cancellare and his now-ex-wife, he would be well aware of her allergy. Apparently, it’s so severe that she had to take extra precautions and alert the wait staff at every restaurant to her allergy. As a result, police believe that the letter was sent with malice as an attempt to harm or even kill the alleged victim.
He was taken into custody and has since posted bond, according to Law & Crime. He has not entered a plea in the case yet.