A family was shocked to learn that the cat they brought to their veterinarian to have humanely euthanized was still alive 18 months later and in the care of one of the workers.
According to a report from The Newnan Times-Herald, Tyler Jagt had owned his cat, Annie, since 2006. However, by February 2025, Annie’s quality of life had declined, and the Jagt family made the difficult decision that it was time to say goodbye. They brought her to the Senoia Animal Hospital, signed a contract and paid $300 to have the cat put down.
“She was very sick, and honestly, I had felt guilty for holding on to her for as long as I had,” Jagt told the outlet. “She had clearly reached the end of her life, she was urinating blood and couldn’t jump up on the chair. She’d meow at the wall at night and lose her way around the house. She was showing early signs of dementia.”
Eighteen months later, a family friend of the Jagts, Courtney Bassin, took a job at the Senoia Animal Hospital and soon discovered that staff determined the cat did not need to be euthanized and, without telling the owners, entrusted Annie to the care of one of the vets there. That vet told Bassin not to tell the family, but she didn’t listen.
Jagt contacted the police, who investigated the situation. The owner of Senoia Animal Hospital, Dr. Jill Phillips, said the decision to keep the cat alive was not meant as a deception, but admitted they hadn’t told the family. When asked what would be done to rectify the situation, the outlet reported that Phillips noted there was no choice but to abide by the family’s wishes rather than go to court.
Senoia Animal Hospital & Pet Resort/Facebook
Annie was euthanized on August 13, and her remains were given to the Jagt family.
“The hardest part of all of this, the thing I can’t get over, is she thinks we abandoned her one day at the clinic,” Jagt told the outlet. “That’s what keeps me up at night. She thought we just left her.”
Despite what happened, Jagt initially forgave the veterinarian who had taken Annie in. During the 18 months she was in the vet’s care, she was reportedly brought back to the clinic several times for treatment.
However, Jagt’s feelings changed when he learned that Bassin, the family friend who discovered Annie was still alive, was fired from her position on the same day the Senoia Animal Hospital euthanized Annie.
“I feel we extended an olive branch to these people, and (Dr. Phillips) turned around on the only person who did the right thing,” Jagt said.
Senoia Animal Hospital denied that Bassin’s firing was related to the incident.